skip to main content
Aug 11, 1997

Siding Manufacturer Nailed For Massive Liability

Featuring: Robert T. Cunningham

The National Law Journal 


Siding Manufacturer Nailed For Massive Liability 

CASE TYPE: liability 

CASE: Naef v. Masonite Corp., 944033 (Cir. Ct., Mobile Co., Ala.) 

PLAINTIFFS' ATTORNEYS: J. Cabraser, Jonathan D. Selbin and Fabrice V. Nijhoff, of San Francisco's Lieff, Cabraser, Heimann & Bernstein L.L.P.; Richard of Mobile's McRight, Jackson, Dorman, Myrick & Moore; Everette Doffermyre, Leslie Bryant and Ralph J. Knowles, of Atlanta's Doffermyre, Shields, Canfield & Knowles; John T. Crowder Jr. and Robert T. Cunningham Jr., of Mobile's Cunningham, Bounds, Yance, Crowder & Brown; Steven J. , Mark S. Willis and Victoria C. Arthaud of Washington, D.C.'s Cohen Milstein, Hausfeld & Toll; Michael F. Ram, of San Francisco's Levy, Ram & Olson L.L.P. 

DEFENSE ATTORNEYS: M. Bickford, of San Francisco's Tobin & Tobin; Robert H. Schulman, of , D.C.'s Howrey & Simon; Steven J. Harper of Chicago's Kirkland & Ellis; Phillip A. Wittman, of New Orleans' Stone, Pigman, Walther, Wittmann & Hutchinson; Sandy G. Robinson, of Mobile's Cabaniss, Johnston, Gardner, Dumas & O'Neal; Broox G. Holmes, of Mobile's Ambrecht, , DeMouy, Crowe, Holmes & Reeves L.L.C. 

SETTLEMENT AMOUNT: driven, up to estimated $ 150 million, according to defendants; up to $ 1 billion or more, according to plaintiffs MASONITE CORP., A division of International Paper Co., has been selling its popular hardboard siding for use on home exteriors for more than 30 years. 

"Until the late 1970s, Masonite made the product properly," said plaintiffs' counsel Jonathan D. Selbin. The pressed wood product requires great heat and pressure to ensure that it can withstand moisture. But, he charged, following the energy crisis of the late 1970s, Masonite "cut back on the heat, and the product became defective." The siding would swell after rainfalls and, unlike natural wood, would not shrink back, he said. Subsequently, homeowners began complaining that the siding was rotting, buckling and generally failing, he said. 

In 1994, some of these homeowners began filing products liability actions against Masonite. In November 1995, a class of Masonite hardboard siding plaintiffs was certified, covering the period from 1990 to the present. 

Masonite denied that the siding was defective. The company blamed any problems on faulty installation.

On Sept. 13, 1996, a Mobile, Ala., jury found the product defective. A second phase to determine damages, including punitives, was scheduled to begin in July. But on July 14, the parties settled. The exact amount will be determined by the number of valid claims filed; Masonite estimates the claims at $ 100 to $ 150 million. "We expect there will be $ 1 billion in claims for the life of the settlement," Mr. Selbin said. The siding has been used on more than 4 million homes. 

On final approval of the settlement, Masonite will pay plaintiffs' counsel $ 47.5 million in attorney fees and $ 2.5 million in costs up front; plaintiffs' attorneys will receive a total of 15 percent of the claims over the life of the settlement, Mr. Selbin noted. These fees are above the amount paid to plaintiffs for replacing and repairing siding.

Lawyer Involved

Related Case

Over $1 Billion

Over $1 Billion paid to homeowners affected by defective Masonite siding & shingles.

Naef v. Masonite Corp, International Paper Co., Cosby v. Masonite Corp., Smith v. Masonite Corp, International Paper Co. | Mobile County, Alabama | Case No. CV-94-4033, Case No. CV-98-2446, Case No. CV-98-2447

Defective hardboard siding and shingles litigations resulting in settlement (after phase 1 of Naef trial) on behalf of four million consumers of pr...

Related News

Dec 28, 1999

Masonite: Godzilla of Class Actions in Mobile

Mobile Register  Series Excerpts  Area's biggest class action also only one that actually went to trial  By Eddie Curran  ...

Aug 21, 1997

Property Owners and Siding Manufacturer Enter into Settlement

Asbestos Property Litigation Reporter  Also:  Consumer Product Litigation Reporter  Mass Tort Litigation Reporter  Siding: ...

Aug 11, 1997

Keep Record of Home Siding Problems

The Indianapolis News  Keep record of home siding problems  Excerpt of column by:  Herman Hoglebogle  DEAR HERMAN:  ...

Sep 01, 1996

AL Jury Finds Masonite Siding Defective; 4 Million People Affected

Mass Tort Litigation Reporter  Naef v. Masonite  Al Jury Finds Masonite Siding Defective; 4 Million People Affected  An Alabama ...

Dec 09, 1995

Masonite Suits Made a Class Action

Chicago Tribune  By Pete Zurales  Mobile Press-Register.  A judge in Mobile (Ala.) County has granted class-action status to a l...

Better Business Bureau Accredited Business

1-251-471 6191 TOLL FREE 1-800-472-6191

Cunningham Bounds LLC Circle Logo
Website developed and designed by Cubicle Fugitive