skip to main content
Feb 19, 2001

Could a $2 Part Have Prevented a Burning Death?

Featuring: Robert T. Cunningham

The National Law Journal 

Case Type: products liability 

Case: Witherspoon v. Mack Trucks Inc., 

CV-97-172C (Clarke Co., Ala., Cir. Ct.) 

Plaintiff's Attorneys: Robert T. Cunningham Jr. of Mobile, Ala's Cunningham, Bounds, Yance, Crowder & Brown: and Gaines C. McCorquodale of Jackson, Ala.'s McCorquodale & McCorquodale 

Defense attorneys: Edward G. Isaacs Bowron and L. William Daniels of Mobile's Pierce, Ledyard, Latta & Wasden 

Jury Verdict: $50 million, reduced to $25 million 

In November 1995, truck driver Tonnie Ray Witherspoon, 31, was carrying a load of logs in a 1993 Mack RD 600 tractor in Grove Hill, Ala., when the 18 wheeler "ran slightly off the road and the load of logs forced it to overturn," said plaintiffs' counsel Robert T. Cunningham Jr. "He was not moving at a high rate of speed, but the truck ended up upside down. He was trapped in the cab," he added. 

A small fire started in the engine compartment, and despite efforts to put out the fire, it gradually progressed. For more than 10 minutes, witnesses at the scene attempted to get him out of the truck, Mr. Cunningham added, but Mr. Witherspoon ultimately burned alive. 

His mother, Mary Witherspoon, filed a products liability/wrongful death action against Mack Truck Inc., charging that "electrical arcing" in the battery system of the truck had started the fire and that Mack Truck could have prevented the fire by installing an electrical cutoff device, or inertia switch, which would have disabled the electrical system in a crash. 

"Numerous studies have shown that post-crash fires are a leading cause of fatalities for operators of large trucks, " Mr. Cunningham said. About 1,000 truckers die each year, he said, about 160 of them in post-crash fires. "A principal source of these fires is arcing," an electrically-induced ignition of vapors. "Arcing occurs when there is damage to the battery cables," and in the Witherspoon crash, "that arcing ignited the fire". "An inertia switch is a simple, inexpensive fix," which would cost about $2 to $3 per vehicle, he said. But, the plaintiff contended, Mack rejected using the switch. 

Mack denied that there were any defects in the truck and contended that an inertia switch was neither necessary nor required, said defense attorney Edward Bowron. "It's not standard in the industry. No manufacturer uses it. It's not mandatory by NHTSA," Mr. Bowron said. Mack did not prevent any efforts by National Highway Traffic Safety Administration to require an inertia switch, he added. Mack also disputed the source of the fire, maintaining that the fire was ignited by the contact of flammable fuel spilling out onto the hot surfaces in the engine compartment of the truck. 

On April 12, a Grove Hill, Ala., jury awarded the plaintiffs $50 million- all in punitives, because Alabama law only allows recovery of punitive damages in a wrongful- death action. On the first day of trial, Mr. Cunningham said, "Mack offered $300,00 to settle, but we never responded." The largest verdict in Clarke County before this was $2 million. 

Mack filed post-trial motions for a new trial, remittitur and judgment notwithstanding the verdict. On Aug. 9, Judge Harold Crow reduced the award to $25 million but rejected all other defense post-trial motions. Mack has appealed.

Lawyer Involved

Related Services:

Related Case

$50 Million Verdict

$50 Million Verdict in Death of Truck Driver

Witherspoon v. Mack Trucks, Inc. | Clarke County, Alabama | Case No. CV-97-172-C

Cunningham Bounds’ attorneys achieved a $50 million verdict in this product liability case wherein a truck driver burned to death in a post-a...

Related News

May 31, 2003

Court Upholds Decision In Trucker's Death, But Reduces Damage Award

The Associated Press  Montgomery, AL  The Alabama Supreme Court has ruled that a company that manufactures trucks was liable in a drive...

Apr 24, 2000

Truck Fire Sparks $50M Verdict

Truck Fire Sparks $50M Verdict  Search for documents is key in Ala. suit over a trucker's death  Margaret Cronin Fisk The National Law...

Apr 20, 2000

$50 Million Verdict Against Mack a Record for County

$50 million verdict against Mack a record for county  April 20, 2000  By JIM COX  Jackson attorney Gaines McCorquodale told a pa...

Apr 13, 2000

Trucker's Mom Wins $50 Million Judgment

Trucker's mom wins $50 million judgment  April 13, 2000  By KAREN TOLKKINEN  GROVE HILL — A Clarke County jury awarded $50...

Better Business Bureau Accredited Business

1-251-471 6191 TOLL FREE 1-800-472-6191

Cunningham Bounds LLC Circle Logo
Website developed and designed by Cubicle Fugitive