skip to main content
Apr 9, 2015

BP’s “Well from Hell” and a Very Big Class Action

Featuring: Robert T. Cunningham

Mobile attorney Robert Cunningham reprises a trial-team view, representing plaintiffs in the worst environmental disaster in U.S. history. 

BY: Chris McFadyen, Editorial Director 
PUBLISHED: April 2015, Business Alabama Magazine 

To read online at Business Alabama.

April 20 is the fifth anniversary of the explosion on the Deepwater Horizon oil rig, which began spewing over 200 million gallons of BP crude oil into the Gulf of Mexico. 

Two years after the spill, the damages claimed by some 100,000 individuals and businesses were combined into a single civil case in U.S. District Court in New Orleans. Most of those claims were covered in a settled agreement reached in February 2012, the night before going to trial. In the resulting settlement document, which ran to more than 1,000 pages, BP agreed to pay what was then estimated to be $7.9 billion in damages, though the estimate has since risen. And in September, 2014, U.S. District Court Judge Carl Barbier issued his findings of fact regarding this first phase of the civil litigation, including the critical finding that BP acted with “gross negligence” and “willful misconduct.” 

For a recap and highlights of the evidence that led to this settlement and the judge’s findings, we talked recently with Robert Cunningham, a Mobile attorney on the plaintiffs’ trial team — one of several teams chosen by the leadership of the plaintiffs’ steering committee (PSC). He is a senior partner with Cunningham Bounds LLC. 

The scope of phase one of the litigation, the class settlement, was to determine liability — liability for a wide range of damages, including environmental damages. The second phase addressed source control (containing the leak) and the amount of oil spilled. Phase three, which was just completed recently, was to determine the amount of damages and penalties under the Clean Water Act. 

The vast majority of the individual plaintiffs were encompassed in the class settlement. People not included in that are those who elected not to be included and chose to prove their individual damages at future trials. 

The PSC was divided into teams at the early start of the litigation, and the trial team went to London and took the depositions of witnesses from BP, the video versions of which were used as part of the case presented. We took over 300 depositions — some of them two- and three-day depositions, and the majority were taken in New Orleans. But some were taken in London, high-level executives. (Tony) Hayward (former CEO of BP PLC) was no longer employed by BP, and there was no way to legally require him to appear in court in Louisiana. We also took a deposition of the chairman of the board, and there was no way to force him to come to the States. 

The key point — and the judge talks about it at length in the 153 pages of his opinion — comes down to the simplest of tests. It’s a test that the well site leaders do before they conclude their work, before they can seal a well — a negative pressure test. They conducted that critical test, but the results were ambivalent. There is no gray area with this test. If it’s a good negative pressure test, you know it’s ok to seal the well. But if there is any ambivalence, then you don’t proceed with abandoning the well, taking the risk of a blowout. They did proceed, and there was a blowout. 

After the blowout, one of the well site leaders tried to explain, in an email to a BP executive in Houston, why they went ahead and abandoned the well. He attributed the ambivalent results of the negative pressure test to what he called “the bladder effect.” The response of the executive in Houston was a whole paragraph of question marks. “Bladder effect?” He’d never heard of such a thing. 

There was evidence to support the proposition that in the last few months they (BP) were way behind schedule and over budget. They had had numerous well control events trying to handle the high pressure that goes with this type of deep well, and they came to call it “the well from hell.” They wanted to get it closed and get out of there. That motivated a lot of what took place in the last days of the blowout. 

Total damages were estimated at the time to be $7.9 billion. We estimated it to be far higher, and, as it turns out, it is going to be far higher. BP now estimates it will be in excess of $10 billion. 

When it became apparent to BP they had grossly underestimated what the claims payout would be, it became a case of buyer’s remorse, so they wanted out of the settlement and used, as a pretext, a few fraudulent claims that had been submitted, and they initiated a propaganda campaign, running ads in the New York Times and Washington Post and Wall Street Journal, saying that the claims process was corrupt. And they made the same claims to the District Court and Fifth Circuit Court and finally to the Supreme Court, and they have been rejected at every step. 

The settlement includes punitive damages in the background, as a risk to BP, and the formulas in the settlement took into consideration punitive damages, which enhanced the amount awarded, and BP still bears that. But, following the settlement, the judge in his ruling found that he was constrained from awarding punitive damages under the law in the 5th Circuit. 

The settlement includes as a big part of it the medical damages to people who suffered injuries during the cleanup and by just having it in their front yard. There are several formulas in the settlement agreement that determine if you qualify. It was not clear that all the medical damages had emerged by the time of the settlement, so the settlement has a back-end litigation option that people can take if they develop health damages down the road. 

The primary vehicle for determining longer-term environmental impact is the Natural Resource Damage Act. NRDA assessments will be ongoing. The United States and the individual states are the trustees in that assessment, and BP is required to fund it. 

I would certainly hope so (that the fines and damages paid by BP make the company more careful). But you have to keep in mind that at the time of the spill, BP was on criminal probation for the (2005) Texas City (oil refinery) disaster, which involved multiple deaths and injuries. And I would have thought the fines in that case — multiple lawsuits and bad publicity and negative outcomes — would have been a deterrent. But it happened again in this case. It seems to me that there is still a risk there that they don’t get it. 

Note: BP PLC’s 2014 annual report, released March 3, reported a 40 percent increase in serious spills in 2014. 
 

Lawyer Involved

Related Case

Over $1 Billion

Biggest offshore spill in U.S. History

Oil Spill by the Oil Rig "Deepwater Horizon" in the Gulf of Mexico | U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Louisiana | MDL 2179

On April 20, 2010, the Deepwater Horizon exploded in the Gulf of Mexico causing the deaths of 11 workers on the rig. It also caused oil to begin po...

Related News

Jul 02, 2015

State Reaches Agreement with BP for Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Damages

Mobile, Ala. – Today, Governor Robert Bentley announced in a news conference that the State of Alabama has reached an Agreement in Principle ...

Jun 03, 2015

AG Luther Strange deputizes private firms for BP case, still plans to keep case in-house

The Associated Press Alabama Attorney General Luther Strange has deputized two private law firms to allow them to assist the state in its laws...

Nov 13, 2013

BP safety commercials betray the oil company's arrogance

Published: Opinion, al.com  By Robert Cunningham Have you ever witnessed the incredible spectacle of a convicted felon bragging about the fac...

Sep 17, 2013

Judge urged to approve BP claims czar's budget

By: Michael Kunzelman, Associated Press  NEW ORLEANS -- The administrator of BP's settlement with Gulf Coast residents and businesses followin...

Sep 17, 2013

Gulf oil spill claims administrator charges BP is trying to 'slow walk' claims payments

By: Mark Schleifstein, NOLA.com | The Times-Picayune  To view at NOLA.com:  http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2013/09/o...

Sep 11, 2013

BP runs misleading oil spill settlement advertisement

Opinion Posted By: Tom Young, The Legal Examiner  Perhaps you have seen the incessant advertisements in The New York Times, Wall Street Jour...

Sep 06, 2013

BP negotiated the settlement it's trying to disown

By: Keith Jones, Contributing Op-Ed Columnist, NOLA.com  To view at NOLA.com:  http://www.nola.com/opinions/index.ssf/2013/09/bp_negoti...

Jul 10, 2013

BP Settlement: Audio Recording of Oral Argument before the Fifth Circuit, July 8, 2013

To listen to the audio recording, please click on the link below and then go to Docket No. 13-30315:  http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/OralArgume...

Jul 09, 2013

The Truth About the BP Settlement

By: Class Counsel  On behalf of the businesses and families of the Gulf Coast, we would like to correct some of the misinformation surroundi...

Jun 30, 2013

BP's "anti-settlement campaign" is contemptible and disgusting

Published: Opinion, al.com  By Bobo Cunningham  To view online:  http://www.al.com/opinion/index.ssf/2013/06/bp.html#comments ...

Apr 16, 2013

BP oil spill trial: BP wells supervisor frustrated by last-minute Macondo changes

BY: Richard Thompson, NOLA.com | The Times-Pacayune  http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2013/04/bp_wells_supervisor_grew_frust...

Feb 26, 2013

First spill trial witness: BP put cost cuts over safety

BY: Kristen Hays, Reuters  http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/02/26/us-bp-spill-trial-idUSBRE91P0NI20130226  NEW ORLEANS (Reuters) - B...

Feb 26, 2013

BP executive resumes testimony at Gulf oil spill trial

BY: Michael Kunzelman, msn.com  http://news.msn.com/us/bp-executive-resumes-testimony-at-gulf-oil-spill-trial  NEW ORLEANS — The ...

Feb 26, 2013

BP Trial: Witness Says Investigation was Incomplete

BY:Tom Fowler, Wall Street Journal  http://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2013/02/26/bp-trial-witness-says-investigation-was-incomplete...

Jun 05, 2012

BP Oil Spill Settlement Conference Announced for Lawyers & CPAs.

BP Oil Spill Settlement Conference Announced for Lawyers & CPAs.  Download the pdf

Apr 18, 2012

Attorneys in BP Oil Spill Case File Documents Outlining Details of Proposed Settlement (Press-Register)

BY: Brendan Kirby  Attorneys representing people and businesses who sued BP PLC after the 2010 Gulf oil spill filed the proposed settlement ...

Mar 06, 2012

$7.8 Billion BP Settlement Would Shut Down GCCF

Source: WKRG TV5  http://www2.wkrg.com/news/2012/mar/05/78-billion-bp-settlement-would-shut-down-gccf-ar-3356183/  BON SECOUR, Alabama ...

Mar 02, 2012

Plaintiffs' steering committee in BP Gulf oil spill litigation announces settlement in principle with BP

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE  March 2, 2012  [New Orleans] -- The Plaintiffs' Steering Committee (PSC) spearheading the litigation surrounding...

Feb 07, 2012

Executive Q & A: Colossal Case Seeks To Pump Justice From BP

Click here to read the article from Business Alabama

Nov 07, 2011

77 More Oil-Spill Claims Against BP (Courthouse News Service)

By: Sabrina Canfield  Seventy-one boat owners have joined the thousands of Gulf Coast residents who've sued BP, claiming it owes them money ...

Sep 16, 2011

Judge Asked to Rule in Favor of Vessels of Opportunity Participants: Local Boat Owners Could be Affected (Press-Register)

By: Brendan Kirby  MOBILE, Alabama — A court filing Thursday in New Orleans could speed litigation by hundreds of Gulf Coast boat owne...

Aug 10, 2011

Boat Owners Call BP's Cleanup Program a Corrupt Conspiracy (Courthouse News Service)

By: Sabrina Canfield  MOBILE, Ala. (CN) - Nearly 100 Gulf Coast boat owners who let BP hire their ships for its "Vessels of Opportunity" oil...

Jul 01, 2011

BP's Ex Chief and Plaintiffs' Lawyers Spar Over Safety (The New York Times)

By: John Schwartz  In testimony before Congress last summer, Tony Hayward, then BP’s chief executive, asserted that his company was co...

Apr 19, 2011

Vessels of Opportunity Lawsuit: BP Broke Promises in Oil Spill Program (al.com)

By Dan Murtaugh, Press-Register  MOBILE, Ala. -- Nearly 100 Gulf coast boat owners involved in the Vessels of Opportunity program sued BP PL...

Apr 18, 2011

Lawsuit Filed for Vessels of Opportunity Participants

Mobile, Ala. – The Cunningham Bounds law firm has filed a complaint in the Circuit Court of Mobile County on behalf of 95 boat owners who pa...

Apr 12, 2011

Deadline to Join Lawsuit Draws Near (WALA)

MOBILE COUNTY, Ala. (WALA) - The deadline to join a federal lawsuit against Transocean and other companies responsible for the 2010 oil spill in t...

Mar 03, 2011

Shrimper Says BP Lawsuit May Be Best Bet (WKRG)

From the Mobile Press-Register  http://www.wkrg.com/alabama/article/shrimper-says-bp-lawsuit-may-be-best-bet/1205222/Mar-03-2011_4-26-pm/&nbs...

Feb 18, 2011

Deadline For Oil Spill Litigation (WKRG)

Original Article From WKRG  New Orleans Court set April 20 deadline for filing claims.  MOBILE, Alabama - People and businesses who ha...

Feb 03, 2011

BP Mediator Feinberg Can't Call Himself Independent, Judge Says (Bloomberg)

By Jef Feeley and Allen M. Johnson, Jr.  A federal judge said Kenneth Feinberg, the lawyer paying victims of BP Plc’s Gulf of Mexico o...

Dec 20, 2010

Baldwin Schools Hire Cunningham Bounds to Handle $4.4 Million BP Claim (Press-Register)

By: Connie Baggett  BAY MINETTE, Alabama — Baldwin County Board of Education members have hired Mobile law firm Cunningham Bounds to p...

Oct 09, 2010

Robert T. Cunningham Appointed To Serve On Plaintiffs' Steering Committee In Oil Spill Litigation

Mobile, Ala. – Robert T. Cunningham, a senior partner at Cunningham Bounds, LLC, was one of only fifteen attorneys chosen by Judge Carl J. B...

Jul 29, 2010

BP, Spill Victims Fight Over Venue for Court Cases (New Orleans City Business)

BY: Simon Shifrin  BOISE, Idaho — BP squared off against a squad of lawyers representing thousands of victims suffering from the oil c...

Jun 14, 2010

Insider at BP Call Center Admits Truth (wkrg.com)

By Lauren Styler  An insider at BP told CBS reporter and former WKRG reporter Tiffany Craig that most of the calls they have been taking nev...

Jun 06, 2010

After BP inaction, Fairhope will deploy its own boom (al.com)

By Russ Henderson  FAIRHOPE, Ala. -- Frustrated by BP PLC's failure to do booming work it had promised, the City Council voted Friday mornin...

May 27, 2010

Oil spill notebook: Company faces suits (Mobile Press-Register)

By Press-Register staff  The company that owned the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig agreed Wednesday to a modified legal order governing clai...

May 26, 2010

Transocean Agrees to Allow Oil Pollution Act Claims to Proceed

Mobile, AL – Cunningham Bounds obtained for its clients a significant victory in the United States District Court for the Southern District ...

May 22, 2010

Leaking Gulf Oil Feeds a Litigation Flood (ims-expertservices.com)

by Robert Ambrogi  Bullseye: May 2010  IMS ExpertServices™ is the legal industry's premier full-service expert witness provider.&n...

May 21, 2010

Legal Landscape For Oil Spills Has Changed Since Exxon Valdez (wkrg.com)

by Bill Riales  MOBILE, Alabama - Thousands of individuals and businesses are submitting claims to BP for lost income due to the oil leak in...

May 13, 2010

Gulf oil spill rig owner Transocean seeks to limit liability to about $27 million (al.com)

By The Associated Press  NEW YORK -- The owner of the rig that exploded in the Gulf of Mexico and set off a massive oil spill will try to li...

May 12, 2010

Cunningham Bounds Files Brief in Response to BP's Motion to Transfer Actions

To view the brief filed by Cunningham Bounds, click here: Cunningham Bounds Brief 

May 11, 2010

BP Files Court Papers to Transfer all Oil Spill Lawsuits to its Hometown of Houston, Texas

On Friday May 7, as BP continued to profess how much it cares about the welfare of the residents, businesses and communities of coastal Alabama, F...

May 07, 2010

Panhandle tourists weigh reservations (Atlanta Journal Constitution)

A sunset wedding on a sugar white Panhandle beach, rimmed with emerald water, is the vision an Atlanta-area bride-to-be hopes will come true. ...

May 07, 2010

Florida Vacation Rental Managers Association Recommends Cunningham Bounds

The Florida Vacation Rental Managers Association (FVRMA) has recommended Cunningham Bounds, LLC to its members. FVRMA is an association of compani...

May 06, 2010

Shelby man, Jeffco firm file lawsuit over oil spill aim to get class-action status (The Birmingham News)

A Shelby County man and a Jefferson County company who own rental property in Gulf Shores have joined a growing number of people filing federal la...

May 06, 2010

Checks coming for fishermen; condo owners, restaurants have to wait (Press-Register)

By Ryan Dezember  Gulf Shores - A manager for the adjustment service hired by BP PLC to vet claims of income lost because of the Gulf of Mex...

May 06, 2010

Property owners and developers along the US south coast bracing for impact of massive oil leak (propertywire.com)

Millions of property owners along the southern coast of the US are hoping that attempts by oil giant BP to cap the leak in the Gulf of Mexico will...

May 05, 2010

Indirect victims of oil spill are on their own (St. Petersburg Times)

By Cristina Silva, Times/Herald Tallahassee Bureau  TALLAHASSEE — Enticed by the sugar sand shore, flocks of tourists arrive at Maria ...

May 05, 2010

Gulf Spill May Be Worse Than Storms, Landowners Say - Update 2 (Bloomberg)

By John Gittelsohn and Nadja Brandt  (Bloomberg) -- BP Plc’s burgeoning oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico may hurt property owners more ...

May 04, 2010

Gulf oil spill lawsuits: Three more filed by Mobile law firm (al.com)

By Brendan Kirby  MOBILE, Ala. -- Mobile law firm Cunningham Bounds, which already represents clients in five class-action lawsuits against ...

May 03, 2010

Gulf Oil Spill Could Be Worse Than Hurricane, Landowners Say (Bloomberg)

By John Gittelsohn and Nadja Brandt  May 4 (Bloomberg) -- BP Plc’s burgeoning oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico may hurt property owners...

May 02, 2010

Click Here For Help or Potential Representation Related to the Oil Spill Disaster

Cunningham Bounds is currently representing many citizens and businesses damaged by the BP oil disaster. Please email oilspill@cunninghamboun...

May 02, 2010

BP told to stop circulating settlement agreements with coastal Alabamians (al.com)

By George Talbot on al.com  May 02, 2010, 8:49PM  Attorney General Troy King has asked BP to cease circulating settlement agreements am...

May 01, 2010

Oil suits flow, but Troy King urges prayer (Mobile Press-Register)

By Brendan Kirby in Mobile Press-Register  MOBILE, Ala. -- The flow of lawsuits has begun, but Alabama's top lawyer suggested Friday that th...

May 01, 2010

BP, Transocean Lawsuits Surge as Oil Spill Spreads in Gulf (Bloomberg)

(Bloomberg) by Margaret Cronin Fisk  BP Plc and Transocean Ltd. face at least 36 lawsuits, including group cases with potentially thousands ...

Apr 30, 2010

Spill of lawsuits follows quickly with Deepwater Horizon oil disaster in Gulf (al.com)

By Brendan Kirby on al.com  The flow of lawsuits has begun.  Prominent Mobile, Ala., law firm Cunningham Bounds has filed a slew of se...

Apr 30, 2010

Multiple Class Actions Filed Over Oil Spill (wkrg.com)

MOBILE, AL - Cunningham Bounds, LLC announces it has filed five class action complaints on behalf of various groups that have been damaged as a re...

Apr 30, 2010

Attorney general to meet with counterparts in Mobile; urges lawyers not to rush to court (al.com)

By Brendan Kirby on al.com  MOBILE, Ala. -- Alabama's attorney general, who plans to meet here Sunday with his counterparts from four other ...

Apr 08, 2010

Cunningham Bounds Ranked in Top 100 Verdicts for 2009

Cunningham Bounds, LLC is pleased to announce that the $20 million verdict the firm obtained inPettaway v. Coastal Anesthesia, P.C., et al. l...

May 08, 2009

Cunningham Bounds Sponsors Law Helpline

Mobile, Alabama - This Friday, May 8, 2009, the Mobile Bar Association along with Cunningham Bounds, LLC will sponsor the Law Helpline in honor of...

Better Business Bureau Accredited Business

1601 DAUPHIN STREET, MOBILE, AL 36604
1-251-471 6191 TOLL FREE 1-800-472-6191 contact@cunninghambounds.com

Cunningham Bounds LLC Circle Logo
Website developed and designed by Cubicle Fugitive