Interest of Justice Requires Venue Transfer When Plaintiff’s Chosen Forum Has Little Connection to the Dispute

|

Ex parte BMSS, LLC, No. SC-2026-0178, 2026 WL 3265584 (Ala. Oct. 30, 2026). The Court (Parker, J.; Stewart, C.J., and Shaw, Wise, Bryan, Sellers, Cook, and McCool, JJ., concur; Mendheim, J., recuses) grants BMSS’s petition for a writ of mandamus, holding that the interest-of-justice provision of Alabama’s forum non conveniens statute, § 6-3-21.1, Ala. Code 1975, requires transferring the action from Jefferson County to Mobile County, where the alleged wrongful conduct occurred and the dispute had its strongest connection. Id. at *1, *6.

Warren Averett, an accounting firm, sued competitor BMSS in Jefferson County, alleging tortious interference with contractual and business relations after six former employees left Warren Averett to join BMSS’s Mobile office and several clients followed them. Id. at *1. The former employees had signed employment agreements containing restrictive covenants, and they filed a separate declaratory-judgment action in Mobile County challenging the enforceability of those provisions. Id. BMSS moved to transfer Warren Averett’s action to Mobile County under § 6-3-21.1, arguing that both the convenience of the parties and witnesses and the interest of justice favored transfer, but the circuit court denied the motion. Id.

The Court explains that although a plaintiff’s choice of a proper forum ordinarily receives great deference, § 6-3-21.1 requires transfer when another proper venue has a substantially stronger connection to the dispute and the interest of justice favors transfer. Id. at *2–3. The Court emphasizes that the interest-of-justice inquiry focuses on where the defendant’s allegedly wrongful conduct occurred, rather than simply where the plaintiff maintains its principal office or experiences financial consequences. Id. at *4. Here, no material events occurred in Jefferson County, while the alleged contractual interference took place at BMSS’s Mobile office, many affected clients were located in Mobile County, and a related lawsuit involving the same restrictive covenants was already pending there. Id. at *4–5. Because Mobile County had a strong connection to the litigation and Jefferson County had little connection beyond the parties’ general business activities, the Court directs the circuit court to transfer the action to Mobile County. Id. at *6.

Related Document

Categories: 
Share To: