Circumstantial Evidence of Pretext Supports Retaliatory-Discharge Verdict

|

Envoy Air, Inc. v. Creagh, No. SC-2025-0022, 2026 WL 3092689 (Ala. Oct. 16, 2026). The Court (per curiam; Stewart, C.J., and Bryan, Mendheim, McCool, JJ., and Minor, Special Justice, concur; Sellers and Cook, JJ., dissent, with opinions; Parker and Wise, JJ., join the respective dissents; Shaw, J., recuses) affirms a jury verdict finding Envoy liable for retaliatory discharge but remands for written findings supporting the circuit court’s refusal to remit the $250,000 compensatory and $425,000 punitive damages awards. Id. at *18.

Creagh injured her shoulder at work and filed a workers’ compensation claim. Id. at *1. After she returned with lifting restrictions, her supervisor allegedly became hostile and threatened to find a way to terminate her employment. Id. at *1–3. Envoy subsequently fired Creagh for allegedly falsifying a physician’s return-to-work note, which Creagh denied altering. Id. at *3–5. Creagh contended that her supervisor fabricated the discrepancy as a pretext for terminating her because of her workers’ compensation claim. Id. at *12–13.

The Court holds that substantial evidence supported the jury’s determination that Creagh was terminated solely because she pursued workers’ compensation benefits, despite Envoy’s asserted legitimate reason for her discharge. Id. at *11–13. The Court emphasizes conflicting evidence concerning who made the termination decision, the supervisor’s hostility, and the allegedly altered medical note, explaining that these credibility disputes were properly resolved by the jury. Id. Although the Court affirms liability and finds no reversible evidentiary error, it remands for written findings explaining the circuit court’s denial of Envoy’s motion for remittitur. Id. at *17–18.

Related Document

Categories: 
Share To: