Letters Seeking Extension to Respond May Trigger Rule 55(b)(2)’s Hearing-and-Notice Requirements

|

DeMike v. Littrell, No. CL-2025-1072, 2026 WL 2795013 (Ala. Civ. App. Sept. 18, 2026). The court (per curiam; all judges concur) dismisses the appeal with instructions, holding that the defendants’ pro se letters requesting additional time to respond constituted an “appearance” under Rule 55(b)(2) of the Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure, requiring notice and a hearing before entry of default judgment. Id. at *1.

Littrell, acting as trustee of two trusts, sued Michelle DeMike and Zachary Hatfield after acquiring title to real property and alleging that the defendants claimed an interest in the property and refused to vacate. Id. Littrell sought a declaration that she held fee-simple title, ejectment-type relief, and trespass damages. Id.

After being served, the defendants filed pro se letters referencing the case style and case number and requesting 90 additional days to respond. Id. The circuit court granted an extension until November 17, 2025, but the defendants filed another set of letters on that date seeking a second extension. Id. The circuit court denied the second extension, and Littrell moved for default judgment the next day. Id.

The circuit court entered default judgment four business days after service of the motion and three business days after filing, granting all requested relief without any indication that a hearing had been scheduled or held. Id.

On appeal, the defendants argued that the default judgment was improperly entered because they had appeared in the action and were entitled to notice and a hearing under Rule 55(b)(2). Id. at *2. The court explains that Rule 55(b)(2), as amended in 2023, requires a hearing and written notice of both the default-judgment application and the hearing at least three days before the hearing when the party against whom default judgment is sought has appeared. Id.

Relying on Progress Industries, Inc. v. Wilson, 52 So. 3d 500 (Ala. 2010) and Evans v. Evans, 441 So. 2d 948, 949 (Ala. Civ. App. 1983), the court explains that a filing may constitute an appearance when it shows an intent to submit to the court’s jurisdiction and defend the action, even if it is not a formal answer. Id. at *3.

Although the defendants had failed to plead or otherwise defend for purposes of Rule 55(a), their letters still constituted an appearance for purposes of Rule 55(b)(2). Id. Therefore, the circuit court’s failure to schedule and hold a hearing and provide the required notice rendered the default judgment void. Id. The court dismisses the appeal because it was taken from a void judgment but instructs the circuit court to vacate its default judgment. Id. at *4.

Related Document

Categories: 
Share To: