Untimely Summary Judgment Responses May Be Stricken, but Unresolved Claims Remain Pending Despite Rule 54(b) Certification

|

Commercial Properties, Inc. v. Charalambidou, Nos. SC-2026-0190 & SC-2026-0191, 2026 WL 3091393 (Ala. Oct. 16, 2026). The Court (Sellers, J.; Stewart, C.J., and Wise, Cook, and Parker, JJ., concur) affirms the trial court’s decision to strike an untimely response to a motion for partial summary judgment but reverses its subsequent order insofar as it purported to dismiss the entire case while certifying the partial judgment as final under Rule 54(b), Ala. R. Civ. P. Id. at *1, *4.

Montgomery Civic Ballet and its executive director and his wife sued their commercial landlord, alleging personal injuries and property damage resulting from mold in the leased premises. Id. at *1. The landlord counterclaimed for unpaid rent, contractual defense, and indemnification and moved for partial summary judgment on claims involving the Ballet. Id. at *1–2. The plaintiffs filed their opposition on the Friday before a Monday hearing, and the trial court struck it as untimely, later refusing to consider a renewed submission. Id. at *2–3.

The Court explains that, under Rules 56(c)(2) and 6(a), Ala. R. Civ. P., as applicable at the time, summary judgment responses were due two business days before the hearing, making the plaintiffs’ Friday filing untimely. Id. at *2. The Court holds that the trial court acted within its discretion in striking the response and refusing to reconsider it, particularly where the plaintiffs had not sought an extension or continuance under the applicable rules. Id. at *3–4. However, the Court reverses the trial court’s dismissal of the entire action because the partial summary judgment did not resolve the individual plaintiffs’ claims or all remaining damages issues. Id. at *4. The Court affirms the Rule 54(b) certification but remands for further proceedings on the unresolved claims. Id.

Related Document

Categories: 
Share To: