Municipal Employees and Municipal Volunteers Enjoy Immunity from Tort Liability for Enforcement of Zoning Ordinances

|

Ex parte City of Fairhope Planning Commission and City of Fairhope, SC-2025-0803, CV-24-900982 (Ala. Oct. 16, 2026). The Supreme Court (Parker, J., and Wise, Sellers, and Cook, JJ., concur; Stewart, C.J., concurs in the result with opinion, which McCool, J., joins; Shaw and Bryan, JJ., concur in the result; Mendheim, J., concurs in the result, with opinion) grants the petition for writ of mandamus, holding certain Fairhope city employees and the Fairhope Planning Commission enjoy immunity from tort liability for money damages where decisions were made in enforcement of zoning ordinances.

The City of Fairhope created the Planning Commission to make decisions regarding approval of subdivisions consistent with the City’s subdivision regulations. *1. Fairhope employs the planning staff, and the Planning Commission has no staff of its own Id. 68V BTR Holdings, LLC, (“68V”) applied to develop two townhome communities. Both applications were denied, and 68V sued the city for actions of city employees and the Planning Commission. Fairhope and the Planning Commission filed petitions for writ of mandamus following the circuit court’s denial of summary judgment on the negligence claim against them based on municipal immunity, volunteer immunity, and substantive immunity.

The Planning Commission members are uncompensated volunteers, Ala. Code 1975 § 11-52-3(b), who enjoy “volunteer immunity” under the Alabama’s Volunteer Service Act, which provides immunity for municipal volunteers “if they (1) were acting in ‘good faith’ within the scope of their official ‘functions and duties’ and (2) were not engaged in ‘willful or wanton conduct.’” Ala. Code 1975 § 6-5-336. *2. 68V did not claim the members acted willfully or wantonly, but instead claimed the members acted in bad faith. *3. The municipal-immunity statute “limits a municipality’s liability for the acts of its agents to those that are negligent, careless, or unskillful,” and also immunizes “the acts of [municipal] agents that are carried out in bad faith.” Ex parte City of Tuskegee, 932 So. 2d 895, 910 (Ala. 2005). 68V’s negligence claims against the Fairhope city employees fail because the employees are immune from suit pursuant to the doctrine of substantive immunity. *3. Substantive immunity provides immunity from tort liability for functions “so laden with the public interest as to outweigh the incidental duty to individual citizens.” See Ex parte City of Muscle Shoals, 384 So. 3d 37, 41 (Ala. 2023).

Related Document

Categories: 
Share To: